How does an ACR accessibility evaluation work?
Producing an accurate ACR for accessibility requires a structured evaluation process. Here are the five stages:
1. Select the applicable standard(s). Choose which framework(s) to evaluate against: WCAG 2.1 Level AA, WCAG 2.2, Section 508, EN 301 549, or a combination. The choice depends on the regulatory environment of the product's intended market.
2. Define the product scope. Specify the product name, version, and exact components being evaluated: web interface, mobile app, API, and documentation. The scope sets clear boundaries for what the ACR report does and does not cover.
3. Conduct the accessibility evaluation. Combine automated scanning (using tools such as Axe, Deque, or Clym's accessibility scanner), manual expert review, and testing with assistive technologies, including screen readers (NVDA, JAWS, VoiceOver) and keyboard-only navigation.
4. Assign conformance levels to each criterion. For each success criterion in the chosen standard, assign one of the four conformance levels above and provide explanatory remarks for any criterion that does not fully support or is not applicable.
5. Publish and maintain the ACR document. Record the evaluation methodology, tools used, and date of evaluation. Publish the completed ACR on your website or provide it to procurement contacts on request. Update it with each major product release.
Is an ACR required under Section 508 and the EAA?
Neither Section 508 nor the EAA mandates the VPAT/ACR format by name, but both create legal environments where an ACR becomes practically unavoidable.
Under Section 508, U.S. federal agencies must ensure that any ICT they procure meets the Section 508 standards. Procurement officers are directed to obtain vendor documentation demonstrating conformance. In practice, a completed ACR using the VPAT template is the universally accepted format. Without one, a vendor is unlikely to pass the supplier qualification stage.
Under the European Accessibility Act (EAA), businesses must ensure that in-scope products and services meet EN 301 549 requirements from June 2025. The EAA requires technical documentation demonstrating conformance. An ACR structured against EN 301 549 is the established method for meeting this documentation obligation.
In both cases, an ACR helps organisations:
- Respond to formal procurement information requests (RFIs/RFPs)
- Satisfy EN 301 549 technical documentation obligations under the EAA
- Demonstrate conformance with WCAG 2.2 Level AA as referenced by Section 508
- Provide evidence during regulatory audits or legal proceedings
- Meet the documentation requirements of major enterprise and public-sector frameworks
What happens when an ACR reveals non-conformance?